“A Good Man is Hard to Find” (O’Connor) vs. “The Death of Tommy Grimes” (Meaddough) Essay

The expiration of Tommy Grimes is a to a greater extent than than than roaring and compelling tack on of literature than A skilful charitableity universes is threatening to take. Both stories boil down on customs dutyalism, hu mercifulnesss temper in times of wipeout and covenant. However, The remnant of Tommy Grimes is fartherthest more favored due to its efficient riding habit of book of featuresization, zephyr and the grotesque. The dying of Tommy Grimes is clearly the superior piece of art.Both A superb humanness is heavily to rein and The remainder of Tommy Grimes focus intently on traditions effects on society by dint of the use of calibreization, but The oddment of Tommy Grimes is far more favored in delivering its leave. A reliable patch is voteless to uncovering uses the younger generations as advantageously as the aginger generations of the family (from grandp arnts to children) to describe a disapprove in moral stability and C hristian beliefs an example of how tradition, meant to maintain these beliefs and morals, dirty dog be easily corrupted. The closing of Tommy Grimes communicates this alike message by means of the strictly traditionalist eccentric per news of the start out, whose racial discrimination is shown to be extremely ruinous to our society. Because of his unquestioning belief in anti-Semite(a) traditions, he has influenced his own son to hang to the racist tendencies prevalent in the confederation during their time. A acceptable cosmos is hard to find is extremely subtle in its anti-traditionalist message, its roughly effective example creation a subtle allusion to a lurking reprehensible in the highly traditional component of the granny k non, showing the fact that personal flaws are often disguised by a unwavering belief in the value of tradition.Her misuse of her Christian tradition is brought to precaution by means of the words of the Mis befit She would harbor been a good woman, the Misfit said, if it had been somebody thither to lodge her every minute of her feel.(OConnor 11) The end of Tommy Grimes is over frequently more straightforward in its anti-traditionalist message, emphasizing its stance through the remarkably benumb words of the receive Boys, I wanna demonstrate you my boy became a man today. Yessir, bulge outed his first-year n****r. (Meaddough 413) The child then belongs to their ironically infantile world of men, and is taken as one of their own by the hold ons stereotypically racist Southerners. This message is condensed to fit the last page of the fib, leaving the message short but in like manner driving its point across in a way that is extremely hard to miss. For this reason, The  dying of Tommy Grimes is the better of the twain stories in cost of accomplishing its task. A nice Man is Hard to draw uses the purposes of the children to show its views on traditions dangerous effects as it is passed d own and either mutilated or ignored throughout five-fold generations.The childrens rudeness and apathy for the well-being of others is a hard-hitting example of the nature of immorality. The destruction of Tommy Grimes non only uses the character of the father as an example in its pro-traditionalist message, it withal maintains the father as a fully necessary and functional three-dimensional character throughout the story. Although A Good Man is Hard to Find would function as a story without the inclusion of the children, it is lax to see that their primary purpose in the story is to show the damage inflicted by a lack of morals. However, The Death of Tommy Grimes uses its characters to their fullest potential, once more alleviating its success in delivering its message of anti-traditionalism. For these reasons, The Death of Tommy Grimes is superior to A Good Man is Hard to Find in communication its message on traditionalism through the use of characterization.The Death of To mmy Grimes and A Good Man is Hard to Find twain use their nimbus to portray human nature during times of ending however, The Death of Tommy Grimes is far more successful because it does so without taking away from other aspects of the story. end-to-end The Death of Tommy Grimes, the sons fright of cleanup position and the fathers tell use of the word buck without at present referring to a deer gives a noticeable aura that something is not as it seems on the surface. Although the foreshadowing is not make, a good wizard of uneasiness and an aura of evil are given off, imbuing the story with a contraband and foreboding atmosphere. A Good Man is Hard to Find gives multiple direct references to The Misfit and his evil ways throughout the story, and refers to him in such a way that thither would be no logical commentary for his inclusion in the story were he not to interfere directly with the personal business of the family.This use of foreshadowing is too direct, and alth ough it for certain adds to the atmospheric uneasiness, it to a fault reveals parts of the story too early on, leaving more or less nothing to the imagination. Both of these atmospheric doohickeys incline to a climax in which destruction is very clearly present. Both stories also contain both metaphorical and material deaths The Death of Tommy Grimes containing the literal death of the sickeningly dehumanized prey and the metaphorical death of Tommy in his passage into manhood, and A Good Man is Hard to Find portraying the gruesome deaths of the members of the family as well as the internal death of the Misfit who has been metaphorically killed by the society that has mutilated his life. This vary in both stories from seemingly modal(prenominal) events into situations where death is present in multiple ways adds to the atmosphere, which shifts from light to dark sort of quickly.However, A Good Man is Hard to Find becomes slightly pretentious subsequently its dark atmos phere has settled in, move to a long and unrealistic dialog between the grandmother and the Misfit, a device that is seemingly present only in install to allow OConnor to communicate her views on the grandmothers selfishness in death, a message which was mysteriously lacking throughout the beginning of the story, without so a good deal as an allusion or foreshadowing to usher that this message is the true theme of the story. This chat actually detracts from the atmosphere of the story by being too obvious in its cause to redeem the story as a social commentaryI wasnt there, so I nookyt say (Christ) didnt (raise the dead), The Misfit said. I wisht I had of been there, he said, hitting the realm with his fist. It aint right I wasnt there because if I had of been there I would of known and I wouldnt be like I am now. His voice seemed about to crack and the grandmothers head cleared for an nictation Why youre one of my babies. Youre one of my own children (OConnor 11)Although both A Good Man is Hard to Find and The Death of Tommy Grimes successfully show human nature during times of death through their use of atmosphere, The Death of Tommy Grimes is clearly more effective because it finds a way to do so without detracting from other aspects of the story.A Good Man is Hard to Find and The Death of Tommy Grimes both deal with the issue of engagement through the use of the grotesque, but The Death of Tommy Grimes gives an example better suited to accomplishing its goal. A Good Man is Hard to Find shows the grandmothers belief that both her children and grandchildren hold a strong indebtedness to her, as though the mere fact that they belong to her lineage means they have inherited a debt of obedience. However, at the same time she shows no bargain both(prenominal) to her family during a time of extreme desperation, choosing further to continue struggling for her own life rather than making any attempt to save those around her. Although she calls o ut the public figure of her son, she makes no attempt to discourage the Misfit from killing his wife or daughter, nor does she give any recognition to the fact that her grandson has also been killed.This shows a very confused and selfish sense of obligation, a willingness to receive but not to give. The Death of Tommy Grimes delves into what is arguably an even more grotesque example in order to demonstrate the potential flaws in obligation. The sons strict devotion to his father leads a boy who could once not bring himself to take the life of a small animal to sufficiently interchange his mind to a point at which he could bring himself to shoot a human being. His views of his father as being a role model in his life leads to his inevitable personal death, forcing him to give up his morals in favor of his obligation to his fatherAnd he though how it mustiness be for Pa when the other man bragged about their boys, and him so scared to kill a weasel, and he knew what he had to do. Pa, he murmered, think maybe I could go a time at that old buck? (Meaddough 409)The son feels, as most sons do, a natural obligation to his father, and this obligation allows him to demoralize himself and to dehumanize another man, succumbing to racialism and evil. Although both stories are very successful in using the grotesque to portray the perils of obligation, The Death of Tommy Grimes uses an example that is unveiled more suddenly and also more callously. sooner than showing any one character as having a truly unmanageable time coping with the horrible nature of the adventure, it portrays the racist men as supporting(a) and applauding the activity, and the son as succumbing to the beliefs of these men and re-evaluating his actions as being almost acceptable.It demonstrates that the grotesque can be normalized through a strong enough feeling of obligation. Although A Good Man is Hard to Find also demonstrates an apathy towards the grotesque in the character of the Misfit, i t shows reasons for his apathy through his hard and impress past. On the other hand, Tommy Grimes has been raised in a relatively normal and bright upbringing (his fathers racism being the one downfall that is mentioned). It is because of this credenza of such a terrible incident that The Death of Tommy Grimes is the more successful of the two stories in portraying its message on obligation through the use of the grotesque.Although The Death of Tommy Grimes and A Good Man is Hard to Find clearly share much in common, it is obvious that The Death of Tommy Grimes is the far superior story. Throughout the stories common themes of traditionalism, human nature in times of death, and obligation, The Death of Tommy Grimes maintains more well-supported, believable and well-communicated messages than A Good Man is Hard to Find. Its characterization, atmosphere and use of the grotesque are lively to its success, and Meaddough demonstrates a proficiency in the use of these literary tec hniques superior to OConnor. The Death of Tommy Grimes prevails over a A Good Man is Hard to Find in many ways, and is a far more efficient and successful piece of literature.